‘Sports Bitches’ Break Down Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl Halftime Booking and the NFL’s Bold Pivot

When the NFL revealed that Bad Bunny would headline the 2026 Super Bowl halftime show in San Francisco, it sparked instant reactions—from excitement to confusion to outright controversy. 

On Sports Bitches, hosts Rachel Bonnetta, Megan Gailey, and Sarah Tiana dive right in, weighing the expectations of a Taylor Swift or Miley Cyrus booking against the reality of the world’s most-streamed Latin superstar. Their take captures both the initial disappointment some fans felt and the more profound appreciation for what this moment actually represents. 

The conversation also underscored a larger point: The League’s choice of Bad Bunny signals a shift toward global relevance, cultural resonance, and even political courage. Let’s unpack it.

Bad Bunny at the Super Bowl Halftime Show Is the Cultural Shift We Need

Why fans initially expected Taylor Swift or Miley Cyrus 

When halftime speculation first landed, Gailey admits she had something else in mind. “I was initially disappointed because I wanted Miley Cyrus. I wanted her to bring out her godmother, Dolly Parton, and her spiritual godmother, Cher,” she says. “I wanted a three-headed diva.” 

Bonnetta and Tiana echoed that many people were expecting the NFL to lean into a big female pop star, especially since Swift had been rumored as the headliner for months before backing out of negotiations. The assumption was that the League would want another universally recognizable act with a massive English-language catalog. 

The power of Bad Bunny’s politics and presence 

Gailey explains how her view shifted once she thought about what Bad Bunny represents beyond the music. “When I saw how upset it made certain demographics of people, I was like, I’m the biggest Bad Bunny fan of all time,” she says. “I do align with like his politics and what he’s been doing. And how he carries himself as a performer in this really fucked up time.”

She points out his decision to cancel U.S. tour dates due to fears of ICE raids at his concerts and instead pour energy into a Puerto Rico residency. “The fact that he has taken all of his U.S. dates off the calendar, has been doing this residency in Puerto Rico that has done so much for the economy, and a place that America has really turned its back on despite it being part of America,” Gailey marvels. “And so now I’m all in on Bad Bunny and I cannot wait.” 

That framing shows why his halftime show matters on a cultural level: It’s a global platform for an artist who has refused to separate his art from his activism.  

Challenging the double standards of performance 

The hosts also address the backlash surrounding Bad Bunny’s performance style, which is often criticized for being “too sexual.” Tiana laughs about TikTok clips, noting, “I don’t think he wears underwear.” That observation might seem lighthearted. But it sparked a bigger point—why is it striking to see men finally critiqued for sexuality the same way women always are? 

As Gailey puts it: “It’s always refreshing if we’re mad at men for being overtly too sexual because that’s usually something that’s only reserved for female performers.” That lens makes Bad Bunny’s halftime show even more compelling. He doesn’t fit neatly into traditional masculinity. And the hosts were quick to notice how his stage presence forces the same conversations usually directed only at women. 

The NFL’s surprising streak 

While some critics grumble, the Sports Bitches hosts give the league credit. Bonnetta points out, “Kudos to the NFL, the last two years in a row. Yes. Kendrick Lamar, who is very outspoken and is going to tell you exactly how he feels. And now Bad Bunny.” 

That’s a significant shift from the safer, nostalgia-based bookings of years past. By handing the stage to artists with political edge and cultural resonance, the NFL is clearly making moves to stay relevant with younger, more diverse audiences. 

Why this halftime show could be unforgettable 

At the end of the discussion, the three hosts agreed: This performance has the potential to be huge. “We’ve settled. We’re excited for Bad Bunny. We’re excited for him,” Bonnetta says. 

Whether or not fans get surprise guests or headline-making theatrics, the energy is already building. For an artist who is the second most-streamed performer in the world and whose politics push boundaries, this is a Super Bowl halftime show that will have people watching—and talking—long after the final whistle. 

Read Next

• Shawn Johnson East Shares How Competing with Her Husband Tested Their Limits on ‘Special Forces’
• Busy Philipps Opens Up About ADHD: ‘I Always Felt a Little Bit Further Behind’
• ‘Sports Bitches’ Says the Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni Lawsuit Is Basically a Group Chat with No Exit Button