3 Ways To Stop Repeating The Same Toxic Relationship Dynamic

You’ve done the work. You’ve identified your red flags. You’ve sworn off emotionally unavailable people. And yet—here you are again, three months into something that feels eerily familiar. Different name, different face, same exact energy. At some point, you have to wonder: is this just bad luck, or is something else going on?

On Dear Gabby, host Gabrielle Bernstein breaks down why we keep attracting the same toxic dynamics on repeat—and how to finally break the cycle. Whether you’re freshly out of another situationship that went nowhere or you’re starting to notice an uncomfortable pattern in your dating history, this convo is for you.

You’re dating the same person in a different body

“You’re gonna literally be attracting the same relationship over and over and over again, just in a different body,” Bernstein explains. “And you’re gonna look at it and you’re gonna be like, how did this happen again?”

It happens because relationships are mirrors. They reflect back what’s going on inside you—specifically, your core beliefs about yourself and what you think you deserve.

“If you had different beliefs, you would not be a match for that relationship,” Bernstein says. “You are attracting relationships that reflect what you believe about yourself.”

This isn’t woo-woo conjecture. Psychologists call it “repetition compulsion”—a term Freud coined to describe our tendency to unconsciously recreate painful dynamics. Modern attachment theory backs this up: our nervous systems are wired to seek out what feels familiar, even when familiar means harmful. We confuse “I recognize this” with “this is safe.”

So instead of asking “why does this keep happening TO me?” Bernstein suggests a reframe: “What is this relationship here to teach me?” That shift—from victim to student—is where the healing starts.

Your triggers are trying to tell you something

“Every single relationship conflict that you have is actually an invitation to grow spiritually,” Bernstein says. “The people who trigger you most are your greatest spiritual teachers.”

Think about it. What’s the common feeling that keeps coming up in your relationships? Feeling unseen? Abandoned? Not good enough? That feeling is the thing that needs your attention—not the person who triggered it.

Bernstein teaches a four-step check-in process based on Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy, an evidence-based modality developed by Dr. Richard Schwartz that’s shown to be effective for trauma, anxiety, and relationship issues. The practice helps you respond to triggers from a grounded place instead of a reactive one.

The 4-Step Check-In:

1. Notice the feeling that gets activated in the moment. Where does it live in your body? Your chest? Your stomach? Your jaw?
2. Get curious about it. What thoughts or sensations are attached to it? Don’t judge—just observe.
3. Offer compassion. Ask the feeling: what do you need right now? Let it answer.
4. Check the shift. Do you feel calmer? More connected? More clear? Those “C qualities”—calm, clarity, compassion, curiosity, courage—are signs you’ve moved out of reactivity.

“When you’re no longer a match for other people’s bullsh*t, you start to attract different relationships into your life,” Bernstein says.

The goal is to have a tool that lets you come back to yourself instead of spiraling into old patterns.

Stop trying to be seen—start seeing yourself

One of the most exhausting parts of a toxic dynamic is the constant audition. The five-paragraph text. The voice note trilogy. The “here’s what I meant” follow-up after the follow-up. You start feeling like if you can just explain it the right way, they’ll finally get it.

Bernstein calls that out: “Healing really begins when you stop asking, ‘How can I make them see me?’ and start asking yourself, ‘How can I see myself right now?'”

Stop treating being misunderstood like a problem you can solve with better wording. In a healthy connection, you don’t need a closing argument. You say a thing once, maybe twice, and it lands.

So when you feel the urge to over-explain, try this “seeing yourself” mini-reset first:

• Ask: what do I need right now? (Reassurance? Respect? A clear plan? A clean no?)
  
• Name the real request in one sentence. If it can’t fit in one sentence, it’s usually not clarity—it’s anxiety.
  
• Make it actionable, not emotional. “I need consistency,” becomes: “If we can’t talk about where this is going this week, I’m stepping back.”

Because sometimes the most self-respecting thing you can do is stop handing someone a user manual for how to treat you.

For the full conversation and more insights, tune into Dear Gabby, streaming now.

Read Next

• Still Confusing Anxiety for Chemistry? Here’s How to Tell the Difference
• A Dating Checklist for Anyone Tired of Choosing the Wrong Person
• Can’t Stop Thinking About Your Ex? Nobody Can Get You Over Them But You