Should You Stay or Should You Go? When It’s Time to Leave a Marriage

Every relationship is bound to hit a rough patch, but there’s a stark line between a season of strain and the moment you realize you need to file for divorce. Figuring out which side of the line you’re on can often feel confusing and overwhelming.

Friends might advise you to “stick it out,” while podcasts promise to “manifest your marriage back to bliss.” No wonder women—especially those juggling careers, kids, and the invisible labor of keeping everyone else happy—feel stuck in analysis paralysis.

That’s why Over 50 & Flourishing deserves a spot in your earbuds. Host Dominique Sachse tackled a listener’s plea for clarity about ending a marriage, offering wisdom that slices through the noise.

Recognizing tough seasons versus divorce decisions

Relationships thrive on honesty, and Sachse spells it out in simple terms. “There has to be openness, transparency, and honesty about the state of the marriage,” she says. When conversations turn into cold wars, she warns that “one person can’t pretend like everything is fine when it’s not because then they’re not listening to you.” If a partner shuts down every serious chat, you’re not just in a rut—you’re on separate roads.

Before jumping to divorce, though, test the communication pulse. Schedule a distraction-free sit-down and share specifics. Ask for the same in return. If mutual listening happens, “then there’s a pathway forward,” as Sachse says. But if attempts to talk feel like shouting into a void, the marriage may already be on the verge of collapse.

Setting healthy boundaries before considering divorce

Even the happiest couples need guardrails. Sachse reminds listeners that “there are hard boundaries around us that need to be in place,” and those rules apply within the family as well. Emotional safety isn’t a luxury; it’s the foundation. When respect evaporates, she urges spouses to declare, “I’m worthy of more.”

Repeated belittling, gaslighting, or any form of abuse isn’t just “tough times”—they’re red flags. Sachse’s blunt directive to protect yourself underscores that no partner, pastor, or therapist should persuade you to tolerate cruelty in the name of commitment.

What to do when divorce is on the table

If honest talks don’t help and boundaries keep shattering, Sachse offers a reality check: “If it gets beyond that and it’s not salvageable or if there is irreparable harm or if there are things that you can’t overlook, then that’s a decision that you have to make.” Notice the ownership—no one else can make the call on your behalf.

Here’s a roadmap for moving from confusion to clarity when it comes to your relationship:

• Document the facts: Keep a journal of incidents, counseling sessions, and attempts to reconcile. Patterns reveal truths feelings sometimes hide.
  
• Consult skilled professionals: Sachse advises, “I would encourage you to make it with somebody skilled in this area and exercise your options.” That means a licensed therapist, financial planner, and—if necessary—an attorney who specializes in divorce.
  
• Run the numbers: Love might be priceless, but separation isn’t. Map out budgets for solo housing, childcare, and health insurance. Knowledge calms fear.
  
• Build your support squad: One trustworthy friend beats 10 social media commentators. Lean on people who respect boundaries and keep your confidence.
  
• Prioritize self-care: Stress hormones spike during marital turmoil. Regular exercise, balanced meals, and good sleep hygiene help you make decisions from a place of strength, not panic.
  
• Set a decision deadline: Give the marriage a defined window for measurable change, such as weekly counseling sessions, transparent finances, and consistent respect. Without improvement, honor your exit plan.
  

Choosing divorce isn’t admitting failure; it’s acknowledging reality. As Sachse puts it, “there has to be discussion about the state of the marriage.” If genuine dialogue leads nowhere, permission to walk away is sometimes essential. Whether you stay or go, the goal is the same—a life marked by respect, peace, and room to flourish.

Read Next

• Denise Richards is the Latest ‘Real Housewife’ To Divorce—And The Details Are Messier Than ‘RHOBH’
• It’s Okay to Start Over and Reinvent Yourself After a Breakup
• Khloé Kardashian Shares How Her Public Divorce Prepared Her for Tristan Thompson’s Affair