Sometimes I Watch Your Content and Think ‘F*ck Her’: An Influencer and Her Follower Get Honest on ‘The Real Stuff’

Sydney doesn’t have Instagram. She lives in rural Colorado, in a 550-square-foot log cabin, with her husband and two children, earning under $40,000 a year. Her family barters sourdough for kale, babysitting for dog sitting, and even scored an espresso machine by trading childcare hours.

Despite the stark differences on paper, Sydney finds a surprising amount of common ground with Lucie Fink. She’s been a follower since Fink’s Refinery29 days, watching on YouTube and seeing shared experiences in their marriages, children, and even celiac diagnoses. 

But when Sydney noticed the gap between their lives becoming harder to ignore, she did something most followers don’t: She wrote to Fink about it. Not to criticize her lifestyle, but to point out that “there’s a quieter voice that isn’t really being featured” in most of the content she sees from influencers living in completely different economic realities. Most creators would have ignored the message or responded privately. But Fink invited Sydney onto her podcast to ask her directly: So, what was your breaking point?

On The Real Stuff with Lucie Fink, the influencer faces a question many in her position avoid: Can you build a career out of relatability if most people can’t actually relate to it? 

Can Relatability Survive Privilege?

The gap

Sydney can pinpoint the moment the illusion cracked. When Fink posted about teaching her son to ski as a winter priority, she wondered if Fink had considered that it takes months of planning for some families to afford the same luxury. For Sydney, that milestone requires financial sacrifice, secondhand gear, and side jobs. “My husband and I have had long discussions about how it’s really important to us that our kids learn how to ski,” Sydney explains on the podcast, “because as teenagers there’s very few options between drinking and poor mental health and having access to skiing.” For the last two years, Sydney’s family has endured “quite a bit of financial strain” to do the thing Fink mentions casually alongside content about vacations and bachelorette trips. 

Sydney explains the core issue with another example. “I have only ever driven the car that was available. I have never chosen a car,” she says. It’s not jealousy; it’s recognition that the baseline of her life doesn’t align with the lifestyle content she sees. Sydney drives a 2005 Dodge Caravan (“It’s just a vehicle that drives”) while Fink uses the experience of buying her first car as content, hoping to help inform other people similar to her on how to navigate the decisions involved in choosing one. For Sydney, watching someone discuss the luxury of choice suddenly felt jarring. “It opened my eyes, not just to your lifestyle, but that this was even a consideration for a huge swath of people,” she tells Fink.

A question of privilege

To her credit, Fink doesn’t shy away from the difficult conversation. “Does it help when creators continue to acknowledge their privilege? Are you hearing that and saying, thank you, I’m so glad you did that. Or are you just thinking shut up about your stupid privilege?” are the questions Fink is hoping Sydney will answer during their hour-long sit down. 

Sydney answers with nuance, but her response is more revealing than reassuring. “It’s neither here nor there,” she says. “It’s like the preview, the credits, it’s the opening song. And it’s like, yeah, I know what I’m getting into. We live different lives anyway, let’s hear the struggle.”

She continues: “It feels a lot more like a business move than a personal acknowledgement of privilege. It’s like, yeah, you have to say that. Yeah, you’re a privileged white girl. Of course.”

Sydney clarifies that “I think probably 90 percent of it is on my side of things, the consumption side,” she says. Still, she notes that the framing matters. And creators can make it more straightforward when something is just a casual choice, such as a fun activity, versus a significant priority, like a basic necessity. That minor distinction helps audiences avoid feeling like the gap is insurmountable.  

“If it’s super important for you,” Sydney explains, using skiing as the example, “having it be something that gets offhandedly mentioned makes it more of a sticking point.”

Beyond parallel lives

Sydney isn’t seeking pity. What she wants is representation—voices like hers that are often overlooked in the influencer-driven media. “There’s a quieter voice that isn’t really being featured of people who are living a different lifestyle,” she says, pointing out that content creation favors those who already have resources, connections, and access. “You kind of have to have these connections to be featured. And so there’s a whole group of people without connections that aren’t being featured.”

And that’s where the episode lands its bigger point. Relatability has always been a currency in online storytelling, but it comes under pressure when privilege becomes the unspoken backdrop. Fink acknowledges as much herself: “Many aspects of my current life and my current financial situation are a direct reflection of the life that I was born into. I have no doubt that I would not be where I am today if I had not come exactly from the background I came from.”

Moments of connection

What makes the conversation work is when Fink exhibits the willingness to sit in the discomfort of the gap, rather than try to build a fake bridge of “understanding” where Sydney comes from. She asks whether Sydney ever watches her content and thinks “fuck her?”

“Not often, but sometimes,” Sydney answers.

When Fink asks what Sydney has that she doesn’t, Sydney doesn’t hesitate: “Freedom. I don’t have to regiment my phone use. I don’t have to regiment my time.” They didn’t have WiFi until this year. No TV. They read books at night.

“We’re outside all the time. We’re in the sun all the time,” Sydney says. “Anytime I consume content that touches on mental health, it is all mental health issues that are based off of lifestyle.”

What if we swapped lives?

Near the end of the conversation, Fink asks: “If the two of us swapped lives for a week, what do you think would surprise you the most?”

Sydney doesn’t hesitate: “How hard it is. I really think I would be in utter shock at the decision fatigue.”

She describes what she imagines Fink’s life to be: Choosing what to wear from more than three drawers of clothes. Choosing what to eat from “a hundred different options of gluten-free food.” Trying to figure out what to do with too many choices. Then creating content about this own form of exhaustion that later gets packaged as “relatable struggles” and sold to brand sponsors.

“I think decision fatigue would glitch me out right away,” Sydney says.

Meanwhile, Sydney lives the life wellness influencers are selling to millions of followers. She has what everyone watching “trad wife” content is supposedly trying to achieve: presence, simplicity, freedom, community, connection to nature, minimal screen time, family dinners, and slow living. But the real difference, in a conversation about two people with parallel lives but vastly different circumstances, is that Sydney doesn’t have the platform—or the desire—to turn her life into content and monetize it.

Read Next

• Surrogacy Isn’t Just for Rich Celebrities—It’s for Real Fertility Struggles
• The Mid-Year Slump Is Real. Here’s How to Exit Your Flop Era
• Forget Immortality. ‘Treated with Dr. Sara’ Makes the Case for Living Fully, Not Forever