Is Gossip Actually Good For Us? We Explore the Surprising Scientific Benefits on ‘What We Said’

You’re at brunch with your girls, and someone mentions that Megan from work has been acting weird lately. Within minutes the table is buzzing—observations are flying, dots are connecting, and maybe there’s even a little genuine concern. Then someone inevitably says, “Wait…are we being mean? Should we not be talking about this?” Cue the collective guilt spiral.

But what if that moment of “are we gossiping?” isn’t the red flag we’ve been trained to think it is? On What We Said, best friends and cohosts Jaci Marie Smith and Chelsey Jade Curtis unpack that exact dilemma—and their take might just flip the script on how you think about sharing information within your social circle.

Spilling tea doubles as a survival strategy

Spilling tea isn’t just for laughs. Sharing information about people’s behavior is one of the oldest safety nets we’ve got. “If there’s someone who’s doing something harmful or crazy, you should be able to talk about that with your friends,” Smith says. And she’s not wrong. Think about how often a heads-up from someone in your circle has saved you. A friend warning you that a guy from Hinge is a serial love-bomber. A coworker letting you know a client has a sketchy history of skipping payments. Even something low-stakes, like finding out your go-to sushi spot recently went downhill. That’s gossip working in your favor. 

The difference between helpful gossip and harmful rumor-spreading comes down to intent and accuracy. Passing along info that protects your people? That’s solidarity. Speculating about someone’s private life just to stir the pot? That’s noise.

No gossip = no friends

According to research on social bonding, sharing information is actually fundamental to building trust and intimacy in relationships. “If you don’t gossip, you’ll be a loser who has no friends,” explains Curtis. Harsh? Maybe. Accurate? Surprisingly, yes.

Run through your ride-or-dies in your head for a sec. Chances are, they were built through countless conversations where you gradually shared more and more about your observations, experiences, and yes, opinions about other people. This isn’t because you’re all terrible people—it’s because vulnerability and trust are built through the gradual sharing of progressively more personal information.

When your friend tells you something in confidence, they’re essentially saying, “I trust you enough to share this sensitive information.” When you respond appropriately (keeping confidences, offering support, sharing your own experiences) you’re strengthening that bond. It’s the original group chat mentality: We’re in this together, and information flows freely among the inner circle.

Gossip is the ultimate vibe check

Ever noticed how talking through someone’s behavior with friends helps clarify your own values? That’s no accident. It’s one of gossip’s most underrated functions. As Curtis explains, sharing information “reinforces group values…It’s like if you’re all talking about something, you’re all kind of agreeing like that’s not okay or this is okay.”

In other words, gossip doubles as a real-time vibe check. When you and your friends swap stories—whether it’s about the acquaintance who flakes on every plan or the coworker who takes credit for other people’s work—you’re collectively drawing the line on what your circle considers acceptable. “[It’s] almost like a moral code amongst you and your community,” Curtis adds. That process matters. It’s how groups set boundaries, reward behaviors they want more of, and hold each other accountable. Far from being toxic, these conversations are part of what keeps your inner circle aligned and healthy.

Your ancestors gossiped to survive, you gossip to thrive

Gossip isn’t some messy habit we picked up in the age of group chats. It’s hardwired into human nature. “It’s evolution,” Curtis points out. “It’s just smarter for survival to talk amongst each other.”

Anthropologists have found versions of gossip in every culture ever studied. In early hunter-gatherer groups, trading intel was how people knew who could be trusted, which paths were safe, and which behaviors could get you shunned. Knowing who pulled their weight and who stirred trouble meant the difference between living another day or putting the group at risk.

Fast forward to now. The stakes might not be life or death, but the mechanics are the same. We still need to know who’s reliable at work and who can be trusted in friendships. Just as important is spotting the people who threaten our peace. That information helps us decide who to team up with, who to avoid, and where to draw our boundaries.

Want the full scoop? Tune into What We Said, streaming now wherever you get your podcasts.

Read Next

• How Long Is Too Long to Date F*ck Boys? ‘Everybody’s Crazy’ Has the Answer
• Hooking Up Sucks Right Now—And ‘What We Said’ Proves It With These Horror Stories
• Dating App Red Flags That Scream ‘Run,’ According to Jaci Smith and Chelsey Curtis