Why Feeling Heard Might Matter More Than Any Valentine’s Day Plan

Valentine’s Day can be cute, sure—but if you’re relying on one night to fix the whole vibe of the relationship, that’s a setup. On Over 50 & Flourishing, host Dominique Sachse and relationship coach Laurie Gerber get into the kind of romance talk that actually matters in midlife—the kind that makes you feel seen. Not “seen” like a grand gesture or a pricey reservation, but seen like your partner is fully with you, not halfway forming their next rebuttal.

“Love isn’t something that just happens to you. It’s actually something that we can participate in creating,” Sachse points out. Gerber then shares a set of clear, doable shifts you can start making right now to rebuild connection and make things work. That means slowing down, listening all the way through, and stopping the habit of treating your relationship like a guessing game. Because, as Gerber learned the hard way, disconnection isn’t usually one big blow-up. It’s a thousand tiny moments where someone feels unheard and eventually stops trying.

Why Feeling Heard Might Matter More Than Any Valentine’s Day Plan

1. Use Valentine’s Day as a reset, not a test

If Valentine’s Day has ever left you disappointed and resentful, this episode offers a cleaner way forward. “I think the commercialization, I think the pressure, I think the extent to which it makes people feel bad, whether they’re in couples or not, either way, the extent to which it makes people feel bad is a real bummer,” Gerber notes.

The real issue isn’t the day itself, but how easily it turns into a silent exam. As Gerber puts it, “It’s the best opportunity for us women to once again test the men in our lives to see if they can read our minds, which is just the meanest thing that we do, right?” Testing creates tension, not connection. Resetting, on the other hand, invites honesty and collaboration.

Instead of waiting to see if your partner gets it “right,” Gerber encourages treating Valentine’s Day like a shared design project. “We design it together. We even meet probably a month in advance and they go, are we doing this at all?” That shift—from evaluation to intention—takes the pressure off.

2. Name the feelings you want instead of the gestures you expect

Stop fixating on what should happen and get clear on how you want to feel. Most disappointment, Gerber explains, comes from chasing surface-level symbols instead of the emotional outcome underneath them. We’re taught to expect the dinner reservation, the jewelry, the candles—but those are just guesses at what might create connection.

Gerber encourages starting from the inside out. “Fill it with feelings cause it’s the feelings you want. The chocolate and the candles are just the path to the feelings, right?” When you lead with feelings you give your partner a clearer target and yourself more flexibility.

This is where her three-sentence “dream” comes in: a short, honest snapshot of what you want to experience, not a list of demands. “What do you want to experience? What do you want to feel, and what could it possibly look like?” When you name feelings instead of gestures, the conversation shifts to possibility.

3. Practice listening without interrupting or fixing

If there’s one habit that quietly erodes intimacy, it’s not feeling heard. Gerber reveals this showed up in her own marriage, and the consequences were bigger than she realized at the time. “When I first found coaching, one of the reasons that I sought help is because my marriage was on the rocks, because I was not respecting my husband. I was not listening to him.”

What made it painful wasn’t malice or intent. It was the constant interrupting, correcting, and redirecting conversations back to herself. “I sincerely thought I was helping,” she admits, only to learn how damaging that pattern had become. Her husband eventually told her the truth: “I cannot get my train of thought back and I stopped trying to talk to you years ago.”

Listening, in this sense, isn’t passive—it requires restraint. Gerber explains that real connection asks you to stop rehearsing your response and stay present long enough to hear the end of the sentence, even when it’s uncomfortable. “Being excellent at love does require self-control. It requires caring about another person’s experience as much as your own.”

4. Choose experiences that invite play and presence

Once the pressure is off and the listening is there, Gerber suggests shifting focus to how you spend time together. The goal is, once again, presence. Experiences that invite play naturally pull you out of routine and back into curiosity, which is often what’s missing in long-term relationships. There are three simple categories: sensual, adventurous, and creative. “It speaks to play, which is what we did as children, and it hooks back to what I mentioned earlier, it’s experience,” Sachse responds to Gerber’s advice. Play lowers defenses. It makes room for laughter, surprise, and genuine closeness.

Whether it’s slow, intentional touch, trying something that feels a little scary, or making something together, these experiences create memories. “We don’t have enough fun,” Gerber reminds us.

When you choose experiences that encourage presence instead of perfection, romance stops feeling like work—and starts feeling alive again.

5. Build romance in small moments

Romance doesn’t live in one perfect night—it lives in what you practice every day. Gerber is clear that no single holiday can compensate for ongoing disconnection. “If I am not celebrating my love, my romance, my sex life with my husband on a regular day, no good Valentine’s Day is gonna save it, truly.”

What actually sustains intimacy are the quiet rituals that make someone feel valued and safe over time. That might look like daily walks, nightly check-ins, or moments of appreciation that don’t come with an occasion attached. “Every single night we tell each other what we appreciate about each other, what we’re grateful for, what we’re manifesting for our lives,” Gerber says of her own experience. “We have this romantic date every morning and every night.”

These small moments matter because they create emotional consistency. They remind both people that love isn’t something you perform when the calendar tells you to—it’s something you reinforce through attention, respect, and presence. Or as Gerber puts it simply, “I want the day to be like every day, which is an epic romance.”

To hear all of Laurie Gerber’s insights, listen to Over 50 & Flourishing wherever you get your podcasts.

Read More

• The Mental Health Questions Everyone’s Googling—Answered Honestly By A Therapist
• If Being Left on Read Wrecks You, This ‘Squeeze’ Episode Might Explain Why
• ‘Girls Gotta Eat’ on Why ‘Protecting Your Peace’ Is Quietly Ruining Friendships