The Pressure to Always Be Your Best Self Is Ruining Your Friendships, According to ‘Live From Bed’

You’ve already drafted the cancel text in your head. Something came up. You’re not feeling great. You’re so sorry, rain check? But the truth is, nothing came up. You’re just tired. Or not in the mood. Or—if you’re being really honest—you don’t feel like you can show up as your best, brightest, most charming self tonight, and anything less than that feels like a waste of everyone’s time. So you stay home…again.

On Live From Bed, host Jade Iovine sits down with Victoria Garrick Browne—former D1 athlete, mental health advocate, and host of Real Pod—to unpack why so many of us treat social plans like a performance we need to be “ready” for. Whether you’re an introvert who needs 48 hours to recover from a dinner party or someone who’s canceled more plans than they’ve kept this year, this one’s for you.

The ‘sparkle or cancel’ trap

“In the past, especially in my 20s, I’d cancel,” Garrick Browne says. “If I didn’t feel a hundred…it was not happening. Because I was just like, I know my 100 percent version of me who will come later…she’ll punish that person that showed up at 50 percent, and I’ll regret showing up at 50 percent and not sparkling in the way that I needed to.”

That word—sparkling—says everything. Somewhere along the way, hanging out with friends stopped being about connection and started being about presentation. It’s no longer just grabbing dinner or sitting on someone’s couch. It’s showing up energetic, funny, socially calibrated. And if you don’t feel like you can pull that off, staying home feels like the better option.

There’s also the snapshot problem. “When you show up at 50 percent after you haven’t seen someone in like two months, you’re like, that’s their snapshot of me,” Garrick Browne explains. “That’s where they think I am in my life.”

So instead of risking that being the version of you they remember, you start postponing. You tell yourself you’ll go next time, when you’ve slept more, when work is calmer, when you feel a little more like yourself again. But next time always seems to land on another long week or another night where the energy just isn’t there. Before you really notice it happening, canceling stops feeling like a one-off decision and starts feeling like the easier choice.

Why we think we have to be ‘on’

The exhaustion isn’t imaginary. That feeling of needing to “turn on” for people is real, and it’s draining. “That’s where I relate to this 100 percent,” Garrick Browne says. “When I start to freak out that the people are coming over or whatever, it’s because I’m like, I’ve got to turn on. And turning on feels exhausting and I don’t want to.”

This is especially true when there’s a wildcard involved. Garrick Browne describes the panic that sets in when a friend casually mentions they’re bringing someone new. “If I know I’m hanging out with my three or four best friends, I feel safe,” she says. “But then if they’re like, ‘Oh, and I’m going to bring this cool girl from work,’ all of a sudden I’m like—and it’s not that I don’t want to be inclusive and I don’t want to meet someone new. It’s just that I don’t feel like I can now be at my level 50 that I am with my friends.”

That’s the crux of it. With your closest people, you can be tired. You can be quiet. But the second there’s a new person in the mix, you feel like you need to perform and suddenly the whole thing feels like work. Psychologists call this “masking”—the act of suppressing your authentic self to meet perceived social expectations. And while everyone does it to some degree, doing it constantly is a fast track to burnout. The more you perform, the more exhausted you get. The more exhausted you get, the more you cancel. And the more you cancel, the lonelier you feel.

Your 50 percent self is good enough

So what’s the move? According to Garrick Browne, it starts with a fundamental reframe: the version of you that exists when you’re home alone is allowed to exist in front of other people too.

“Recognizing that the Jade that is home alone is a good enough version of you to be the version of you in front of people as well,” she tells Iovine. You don’t have to level up just because someone else is in the room.

Garrick Browne has been testing this theory—treating it like exposure therapy. “I’ve been trying to push myself to be like, yes, you can,” she says. “You can show up the exact same way you would have showed up to this dinner with or without this new person being there. You can host people and not feel like you need to get up and ask everyone if they need anything. You can do it differently.”

The goal isn’t to become someone who loves socializing all the time. It’s to stop believing that low-energy you isn’t worth showing up. Because here’s the thing: your friends probably don’t need you to sparkle. They just need you to be there.

Want to hear the full conversation? Tune into Live From Bed wherever you get your podcasts.

Read Next

• Everyone’s ‘So Busy’—And It’s Ruining Our Friendships, Says ‘What We Said’
• Stop Begging Friends To Care About You—’Give It To Me Straight’ Says If They Wanted To, They Would
• Still Friends With Your Ex? ‘Scheananigans’ Says You Might Be a Psychopath