Podcasting 101

10 Podcasts Like Monster Party: Retro Rants with a Twist

By Dear Media | May 26, 2025

Let’s be real; we consider ourselves podcast connoisseurs here at Dear Media. You all know our line-up is packed with incredible shows and even more amazing hosts (which, by the way, you can see a few of them IRL at our upcoming events!) But we also show love to high-quality podcasts off of Dear Media like “Monster Party!” Sci-fi and horror fans, if you’re not tuned in yet, WYD???

And here’s the thing about “Monster Party”: they’re not just boringly talking about sci-fi, horror, and monsters and calling it a day. They have the perfect blend of humor and personality to make anyone a die-hard fan.

So, if you’re like us and have already binged every episode of “Monster Party” (or maybe you’re just craving a little more creature-feature chaos), you’ve come to the right place. We’ve rounded up tons of podcasts like “Monster Party” that will scratch that same spooky itch.

10 Podcasts Like Monster Party: Retro Rants with a Twist

Before diving straight into the recs, we’ve gotta take a second to talk about what the “Monster Party” podcast is all about. Getting the inside scoop is what will get you excited, right???

Maybe you’re completely new to the show, or maybe you’ve had enough of replaying the same episodes and are pod-surfing for similar content. Either way, we’ll give you the quick lowdown so you can see what makes this show so special.

What Is The Monster Party Podcast About?

Consider the “Monster Party” podcast a vibrant celebration of all things sci-fi, horror, and pop culture. It’s hosted by James Gonism, Shawn Sheridan, Larry Strothe, and Matt Weinhold four seasoned horror fans with deeeep ties to the Comic-Con community. But they’re not just dedicated to their theme; they’re dedicated to humor, nostalgia, and insightful discussion.

Each episode covers a wide range of topics from classic monster movies to unique collectibles and sometimes features fun special guests to chime in on the convos. And look, we’ll be the ones to say it: a podcast lives or dies by its hosts. If a host seems bored or unsure of what they’re talking about, we’re out! But these four? Yeah, they know what they’re doing.

All seriousness here “Monster Party” really stands out for its commitment to celebrating its niche. From praising cult classic horror films to delving into the art of sound design in these films, these hosts are here and excited to talk about it. Some of our fave episodes from “Monster Party” are:

Whether you tune in as you multitask chores or sit back and give it your full attention, this podcast fits every vibe. Now that you’ve got a little inside scoop (or refresher) on what this podcast is about, let’s dive into some fresh new recs!

What Podcasts Are Like Monster Party?

Colors of the Dark

If you’re a fan of horror films and feel like you can’t get enough inside knowledge, this podcast’s for you. Hosted by horror experts Dr. Rebekah McKendry and Elric Kane, “Colors of the Dark” focuses on a different horror film in each episode. You learn more about the filmmakers, actors, the film’s evolution, and its impact on society they cover it all.

And trust us, they have something here for everyone. Whether you’re a fan of new-age horror or stay committed to those nostalgic cult classics, there’s nothing left behind. If you love those behind-the-scenes moments from directors and producers, check out this episode of Him & Her Show!

Curious Matters Anthology

Love tuning into a super immersive story that isn’t quite as long as an audiobook? “Curious Matter Anthology,” hosted by Jonathan Pezza and Alison Haislip, adapts stories from sci-fi and horror writers to create captivating tales that will keep you hooked.

“Curious Matters Anthology” has multi-episode-length stories and single-episode-length stories. So, if you want a fun and quick listen or something deep and continuous, you’ll have no trouble finding either here.

Horror Movie Talk

Two things we love: horror movies and movie reviews. Sometimes a movie is so good that we want to talk to anyone and everyone about it. “Horror Movie Talk” is hosted by Sydney Lee, Bryce Hanson, and Max Allen a group full of entirely different personalities that mesh together so well.

Each episode features a different film (new and old), full of hilarious opinions and relatable commentary. Basically, this podcast is like if “Colors of the Dark” and “Monster Party” had a little pod-baby, ya know? And as far as the inside scoop for scary movies goes, check out this episode of Live From Bed to hear FKA Twigs give us all the deets about “The Crow.”

The Boo Crew

Where do you lead horror and sci-fi enthusiasts to get them excited? Straight to Spotify to listen to “The Boo Crew.” We’re obsessed with the hosts Leone D’Antonio, Trevor Shand, and Lauren Sand and not just because they’re hilarious AF.

Like Monster Party, they’re heavy on the sci-fi and horror movie deep-dive sh*t. In addition to discussing general films, they also explore more about the artists, actors, authors, and personalities who make these films. We want all the tea, and this group doesn’t hold back.

The Night Vale

Sooo let’s talk about “The Night Vale” because it’s truly iconic. It doesn’t have that same horror/sci-fi movie review vibe, but any “Monster Party” fan will eat this up just as much.

In the small desert town of “Night Vale,” Cecil Palmer hosts a rundown local radio show. Cecil reports on all these strange and spooky things that happen in town, yet nobody seems to care. We’re not giving anything away tune in ASAP for the whole immersive story. And, speaking of podcast-turned-storytimes, check out The Readheads Book Club! It has the same vibe and is just as intriguing.

Lore

This podcast is so good that they had to make a TV show and a book series about it if that doesn’t make you wanna tune in, we don’t know what will. “Lore,” hosted by Aaron Mahnke, is giving major “Monster Party” vibes. And honestly? This is what sparked our shameless obsession with it.

This podcast dives deeper into those real-life scary stories that just feel unanswered. Think aliens, bigfoot, ghosts, and mermaids things that don’t feel real but are great for “around-the-campfire” stories.

Monsters Among Us

Another podcast that makes us channel our inner “Monster Party,” Derek Heyes’ “Monsters Among Us,” invites people onto the pod to talk about their personal encounters with all things spooky.

We don’t just mean like… “I thought I saw a ghost,” kind of stuff. We mean UFOs, alien abductions, bigfoot encounters, unexplainable creatures that sort of thing. Grab your blanket and turn on a light; you won’t wanna listen to this one in the dark. For more on this same kind of content, check out this episode of De-Influenced with Dani and Jordan.

Last Podcast On The Left

Honestly, we’re not sure what’s scarier real-life horror or the stuff that feels made up. Either way, “Last Podcast On The Left” dives deep into both realms.

Hosts Marcus Parks, Henry Zebrowski, and Ed Larson are super similar to the “Monster Party” crew funny, honest, and knowledgeable about their sh*t. Between tales of real-life cults to demon-infested horror stories they’re here to chill us to the bone in any way they can.

After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds, & the Paranormal

Hosts Anthony Delaney and Maddy Pelling are taking us to the spookiest corners of horror and sci-fi, so come prepared. They don’t just dive into UFO sightings and paranormal experiences, though they talk about the real dark sh*t history has tried to cover up.

Like what Abraham Lincoln’s final days looked like, where the colony of Roanoke went, and what really lies behind folklore history. Imagine your high school history class, but it’s actually intriguing and you can’t stop thinking about what you learned.

The NoSleep Podcast

If you’ve ever ventured into the dark corners of the r/NoSleep subreddit, you already know what to expect with this podcast. Anddd if you haven’t, you’re in for a spooky treat.

Each episode features a new scary story, typically completely unrelated to the previous ones. And look, they may be fictional, but they make us triple-check our doors and sleep with a light on. So, it’s not exactly like “Monster Party,” but it definitely echoes the same eerie stories you’ll recognize from the films they dive into.

**Which one of these podcasts like Monster Party will you be tuning into first?**

As big of “Monster Party” fans as we are, who doesn’t love stumbling on a few new faves to tune into? Each podcast brings its own unique vibe, but they all have one thing in common: horror, sci-fi, and just enough humor to break up the chills.

Wanna add more podcasts to your must-listen-to list? Check out these posts:

Check out the Dear Media blog for anything from the latest pop culture updates to essential relationship advice. And, don’t forget to check out the DM shop for tons of must-have products! This “Safe, Kind, & Hot” Crew is basically like your safety net while you listen to these super spooky podcasts.